Client Login Free Energy Physical

Market Info & Updates

What El Niño and LNG costs could mean for winter energy prices

1 min read
Aerial view of a liquefied natural gas (LNG) tanker docked at a coastal terminal beside storage tanks and pipelines.

Topics: Natural GasPJMNYISOERCOTISO-NE

Services: Procurement & Risk ManagementReliability

Industries: All industries

A warm winter could bring lower natural gas prices. But in the Northeast, the fuel needed on cold days is getting more expensive. Even with a strong El Niño in the forecast, energy buyers still face the risk of higher prices when cold weather arrives.

Heading into winter 2026–27, those two forces are moving prices in different directions. Expectations for mild weather are helping natural gas prices fall in much of the country. In the Northeast, higher costs for imported fuel are pushing prices up. The outlook for your business depends in part on where your facilities are located.

How Europe’s weather can affect Boston energy prices

The connection starts with liquefied natural gas, or LNG. Europe imports LNG from the United States and through the Strait of Hormuz, which has seen limited traffic due to the Middle East conflict. Disruptions to shipments through the strait have made Europe more dependent on U.S. exports. Europe had little gas in storage coming out of last winter, and, as shown by the blue line in Figure 1, its supplies remain unusually low heading into this winter. LNG prices are also much higher than a year ago.

Line chart comparing European natural gas storage from 2021–2026. The 2026 blue line rises from about 1,000 billion cubic feet in spring to 2,800 in October, below most recent years and the roughly 4,000 billion cubic feet capacity.
Figure 1: European natural gas storage levels, Celsius Energy [1]

Boston also needs imported LNG on the coldest winter days to keep up with demand. When that demand is high, the pipelines running through New York cannot deliver enough gas to New England. LNG helps fill that gap, but buyers in Boston have to compete for cargoes in the same market as European buyers.

That connection is showing up in the price of gas for delivery to Boston in January and February 2027. As shown in Figure 2, prices rose after cold weather last winter, then rose again when the Strait of Hormuz shut down on March 1. Since then, changing expectations about the conflict have continued to move prices.

How long the disruption lasts matters. Prices rose when hostilities began and have reached new highs as the disruption has continued. With Europe still short on stored gas, the cost of buying an LNG cargo for a cold week in Boston remains a concern.

Algonquin natural gas prices for January–February 2027 delivery, rising from about $12 to nearly $22/MMBtu, with annotations highlighting winter cold and geopolitical and LNG volatility.
Figure 2: Algonquin Boston winter 2027 natural gas futures, 5

The effects reach beyond New England

The pipelines that supply Boston connect to pipelines in New York and New Jersey. When gas becomes more expensive in Boston, that can affect prices farther south too. So far, the increase in New York and New Jersey LNG prices has been smaller than in New England.

Electricity prices are more closely connected. New York and New England buy and sell electricity to each other and rely on each other during cold weather. That means New York electricity prices can rise and fall sharply along with New England’s, even when New York gas prices move less.

ISO-NE Massachusetts winter electricity prices have seen sharp swings, as shown in Figure 3. Farther south, prices in PJM East, which includes New Jersey, eastern Pennsylvania and Delaware, have stayed within a much narrower range (Figure 4). That region gets more influence from gas produced in Appalachia, and the effect of higher LNG costs becomes smaller farther west.

Line chart of January–February 2027 electricity prices, rising from about $113/MWh in July 2025 to $154/MWh in October 2026, with winter cold and geopolitical/LNG volatility highlighted. Prices peak near $184/MWh.
Figure 3: Boston winter 2027 electricity futures, 5
Line chart of January–February 2027 electricity prices, rising from about $80/MWh in July 2025 to $105/MWh in October 2026. Annotations highlight winter cold and more muted volatility, with prices peaking near $107/MWh.
Figure 4: PJM East winter 2027 electricity futures, 5

Natural gas is not the only fuel affecting Northeast electricity prices. On cold days, some power plants switch to fuel oil because there is not enough pipeline capacity to supply both heating and electricity generation. But, as shown in Figure 5, diesel and fuel oil are also more expensive this year. Switching fuels does not necessarily mean a lower cost for making electricity.

NY Harbor ultra-low sulfur diesel futures for November 2026 rise sharply from roughly $2 in early 2026 to nearly $5, then ease to about $4.50.
Figure 5: New York Harbor diesel and heating oil futures, CME Group [2]

El Niño expectations have already moved the market

In much of the country, natural gas prices have been falling as the market expects a strong El Niño and a mild winter. Those expectations are already built into prices.

As shown in Figures 6 and 7, the winters of 2015–16 and 2023–24 offer two examples of what a strong El Niño winter can look like. Both had a very warm December, a January with a mix of warmer and colder conditions, and a warm February. Natural gas prices during those winters were among the lowest seen since the NYMEX Henry Hub contract began trading.

U.S. maps showing temperatures compared with the 1991–2020 average. December and February were warmer across most regions, especially the northern and central states. January was colder across much of the West, central and southern U.S., with warmth in the Upper Midwest and Northeast.
Figure 6: Winter 2015–16 temperatures compared with 1991–2020 averages [3]
U.S. maps showing temperatures compared with the 1991–2020 average. December was warmer in the East and colder in much of the West. January brought colder conditions across the South and warmth across the North. February was warmer across most regions, with cooler conditions in parts of the Southeast.
Figure 7: Winter 2023–24 temperatures compared with 1991-2020 averages [3]

There are other winters with mild weather to compare, so those two examples cannot tell us for certain what will happen this year. Still, the market has been expecting a similar result, and natural gas prices have fallen as that forecast has developed.

The specific geographic market also matters. NYMEX Henry Hub reflects the price of gas in Louisiana. Figure 8 shows that price has been falling with expectations for a mild winter. Boston faces the added cost of bringing in LNG, which has been moving in the opposite direction. A lower Henry Hub price does not mean the gas delivered to every location will become cheaper by the same amount.

Line chart comparing NYMEX Henry Hub natural gas futures for November 2026–March 2027 and April–October 2027. Both peak in 2022 and decline through late 2026, with winter prices consistently higher than summer prices.
Figure 8: NYMEX Henry Hub Futures - withdrawal and injection seasons, 5

A warmer winter overall can still include cold spells and winter storms are still likely during an El Niño year. Temperature severity and the duration of colder weather will ultimately determine the effect on prices and the grid.

PJM and ERCOT face different reliability questions

In PJM, the intensity and length of a cold spell matter. The mix of power plants supplying the region has not changed much in recent years. That leaves PJM facing many of the same challenges if another large winter storm brings very cold weather for a long time.

PJM also supplies electricity to neighboring regions. When it has less electricity to spare, it has less available to export. A storm that affects several regions at once could put pressure on PJM and the areas around it.

ERCOT has added more solar power and battery storage, improving its ability to handle cold weather compared with several years ago. That does not guarantee it could get through another Winter Storm Uri without problems, but it is much better prepared to handle a storm than it was six years ago. The amount of excess electricity available above forecasted demand is growing in ERCOT, but shrinking in PJM. ERCOT’s winter electricity prices have been falling, as shown in Figure 9. Recent sharp swings in PJM’s prices for immediate delivery have added to concerns about how much supply it has to spare. Those concerns have made it harder for prices for future electricity delivery to fall, even as natural gas prices decline.

Line chart of ERCOT North electricity prices for January–February 2027 delivery, peaking near $83/MWh in spring 2024 before falling to about $50/MWh by October 2026. Annotations mark March 1 and declining NYMEX Henry Hub natural gas prices.
Figure 9: ERCOT North winter 2027 power futures, 5

Waiting for spring carries its own risk

If your electricity contract expires this fall, should you sign a short contract and wait until spring to make a longer purchase? The answer likely depends on your market. A warm winter could help prices fall, but the market is already expecting that warmth. Cold weather could still push prices higher, especially in the Northeast, where LNG and fuel oil are more expensive.

One option is to buy part of what you need now and purchase the rest later. For example, you could secure a price for 50% of your electricity needs for the next two years, then buy the remaining 50% at another time. Both purchases cover the same two years. With this approach, you’re spreading out when you buy, rather than choosing one day to set the price for everything.

The same idea applies if you still need to buy energy for this winter. Covering some of your December and January needs now can help protect against higher prices during a cold spell. If the winter turns out to be warm and prices fall, you could still have room to take advantage of lower prices for later delivery periods.

Waiting could bring an opportunity, but leaving your entire winter budget dependent on warm weather carries risk. Your energy advisor at 5 or account manager can help you decide how much to buy based on your locations and how much price uncertainty your business can handle.

Sources

  1. Celsius Energy. European Natural Gas Inventories. Data sourced from Gas Infrastructure Europe (GIE). 

  2. CME Group. NY Harbor ULSD Futures, November 2026 Contract.
  3. National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. Precipitation: Monthly Average for 1991–2020, CONUS.

Written by

Updates from 5

Know what’s moving energy markets in real time

Get market analysis and practical advice from 5’s energy experts delivered to your inbox.

×
Bill Conway excited to hear from you

We're stoked to hear from you