Find Us

5 Headquarters

4545 Fuller Dr. Suite 412
Irving, TX 75038
Phone: (972) 445-9584
Toll Free: (855) 275-3483
Fax: (855) 329-3493 
email5@energyby5.com

5 - Northeast

865 State Route 33
Ste 3 PMB 1077
Freehold, NJ 07728
Phone: (732) 774-0005
Fax: (855) 329-3483
email5@energyby5.com

5 - Mexico

CP 11000, Miguel Hidalgo
CDMX, Mexico
Phone: +5595287982
mexico@energyby5.com

LEARN

Category: Markets PJM

PJM East and West United in Historic Lows

July 30, 2020

Written By: 5

Markets - PJM

One might expect significant variations in price movements in an electricity market that spans half the continental United States, from Chicago to New Jersey. However, there is a remarkable degree of consistency in spot (index) prices and in the forward electricity curves across the PJM Interconnection (PJM). 

At the western edge of PJM, spot prices in 2020 have continued to settle below historical index prices over the last six years. Figure 1 shows the monthly spot settlement price in Chicago/Com from 2014 through the first seven months of 2020. Note that the highest index settlement prices were in calendar year 2014 (blue line), when the Polar Vortex came across the Northeast and Midwestern parts of the country. So far, calendar year 2020 (purple line) has settled below all other years since 2014. Demand destruction due to the coronavirus and a relatively mild winter is likely the cause of the distinct separation between prices from March through May in 2020 compared to other years.

Year Over Year Spot Electricity PJM ComEd Real Time LMP

Figure 1: Year Over Year Spot Electricity PJM ComEd Real-Time LMP, by 5

Futures prices are remarkably flat out to calendar year 2025.  Figure 2 shows the 48-month forward wholesale trading ranges at the Chicago/Com Ed trading hub.  The height of the green bar shows the 4-year range of low and high prices for gas in the calendar years shown on the x-axis.  The black bar shows where prices are trading as of 7/27/20.  This chart shows that wholesale electricity prices for calendar years 2021 through 2025 are near the bottom quartile of the four-year historical trading range with a difference of only $1.12 per MWh between the current prices for the highest priced year (2021 at $24.10) and the lowest priced year (2023 at $22.98).  These are good purchasing signals for clients that are seeking budget stability for next several years.

Historical Trading Range PJM ComEd

Figure 2: Historical Trading Range PJM ComEd, by 5

The trends in the eastern part of PJM are very similar to observations in Chicago.  Figure 3 is similar to Figure 1 and shows the monthly spot settlement price at the PJM East (Eastern PA & New Jersey) trading hub from 2014 through the first half of 2020. While the trends are similar, the price differences are significant. 

In January 2014, prices at the PJM East hub settled at nearly $146.61/MWh, while in Com Ed prices settled at $75.37/MWh. As in the western part of PJM, spot prices for the first half of 2020 (purple line) have also settled below all other years.

Year Over Year Spot Electricity PJM East Real-Time LMP

Figure 3: Year Over Year Spot Electricity PJM East Real-Time LMP, by 5

Futures prices in PJM East are also relatively flat out to calendar year 2025. Figure 4 is similar to Figure 2 and shows the 48-month forward wholesale trading ranges at the PJM East trading hub as of 7/27/20. This chart shows a small discount in wholesale electricity from 2021 to 2023 and slight premium in calendar years 2024 and 2025. Overall, however, there is little difference between the lowest priced year (2023 at $27.10) and the highest priced year (2025 at $28.72). These are also good purchasing signals for clients that are seeking budget stability for next several years.

Historical Trading Range PJM East

Figure 4: Historical Trading Range PJM East, by 5

Other Recent Posts

Featured Image

Support at 5

By 5
June 26, 2025

READ MORE >
Featured Image
2 min read

What Congress' Reconciliation Bill Means for Renewable Energy Incentives

By 5
June 25, 2025

The hottest topic in energy regulation is the President’s reconciliation bill. As passed by the House, the legislation effectively terminates the Investment Tax Credit (ITC) and Production Tax Credit ... READ MORE >
Featured Image
4 min read

How the Israel-Iran Conflict is Moving U.S. Energy Prices

By 5
June 25, 2025

During the overnight hours of June 12 and 13, Israel conducted the first of several air strikes against targets in Iran. Over the hours and days that followed, multiple counterattacks occurred, awaken... READ MORE >